Tuesday, May 14, 2013

RIGGING SCANDALS, STREET SHOWS and DATA PANDITS


RIGGING SCANDALS, STREET SHOWS and DATA PANDITS
Have Protesters trust on Courts? Or it is
SAME OLD STORY….SAME OLD POLITICS
Aamir Riaz May 14th
First democratic transition still in the trouble, this time not due to non-elected elite but by a political party which took majority in KyberPK in the same election. Normally, street power is considered as last resort and if you have no trust on courts & relevant institutions then one can use street power. After May 11 election results all political parties are blaming fellow political parties for selective rigging.  Till this time ECP has announced result of 258 seats out of total 272 seats. Now 14 seats are remaining and at NA 250 ECP has announced re-election schedule for May 19. Among 13 seats, elections has been terminated at NA 254 (Karachi) and NA 83 (faislabad), NA 38 (FATA) elections has been postponed while at NA 269 ( khuzdar) has been withheld. Results for 9 NA seats are still in waiting i-e NA 41, 266, 260, 230, 229, 216, 210 & 171. Except Karachi’s massive rigging at selective seats, the situation was not as bad in general yet the situation changed when Mr. Mudassar rizvi of FAFEN appeared in a prime TV show @ Geo channel at Monday and gave a exaggerated story regarding rigging.  Next day print media too picked that news and according to daily time report
Talking to a private TV channel, FAFEN CEO Muddasir Rizvi said that in at least 120 polling stations, the turnout remained more than 100 present and in several other polling stations, the turnout was recorded at more than 300 present.

Although the ratio was to low  too got such space in media, as out of 70,000 polling stations , the smart consultant pointed out only 120 polling stations yet same evening Mudassar’s data was removed from FAFEN website and now there is a regret and clarification pasted there. You may read the content of that statement cum clarification at
ISLAMABAD, May 14, 2013 – The Free and Fair Election Network (FAFEN) would like to clarify the list of 49 polling stations with more than 100% voter turnout released on May 13, 2013.  The data was based on reports of citizen observers trained to monitor the voting and counting processes on Election Day. 
FAFEN regrets inaccuracies pointed out by Returning Officers in Nowshera, Charsadda and Rawalpindi and would like to correct the record for three polling stations.  According to official Statements of the Count, the voter turnout in PS-155 in NA-6 was 56%; in PS-113 in NA-7 the turnout was 64%; and in PS-238 in NA-52 the turnout was approximately 50%.
Inaccuracies in FAFEN’s data might have been due to human errors by volunteer citizen observers in transcribing numbers by hand from Statements of the Count late at night on Election Day.  The errors also could be due to changes in the polling station numbers as listed in the polling schemes, which changes the number of registered voters at each station used as the basis for the calculation. 
The purposes of FAFEN’s report were to urge Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) to release polling station-wise data before certifying election results in any constituency, which will help reveal any problems that require further investigation and action. 
Release of polling station data will enhance electoral transparency and also help address allegations of rigging by political parties and their supporters.  An objective analysis of polling station vote counts and corrective actions by ECP in cases of irregularities will enhance public confidence in the electoral process.
Protestors used that information at social media and in their camps. Such data not only confused people at large but also gave relief to MQM massive rigging at Karachi too. On the other hand statements by other international observers were based on rational analyses and one fine example is NDI report. I-e
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT OF THE NATIONAL DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTE-
ASIAN NETWORK FOR FREE ELECTIONS INTERNATIONAL ELECTION OBSERVATION MISSION PAKISTAN.

Among the protestors PTI workers are at forefront while J.I, JUI, PML (N), Akhtar mengal party, PPP and MQM also followed the path. All of them are pinpointing selective rigged constituencies from where their candidates lost. As a layman, through media we witnessed massive rigging in Karachi Hyderabad yet all other stories are based on hearsay.  In a situation where we have an independent ECP and free courts, is it a good example to take this issue on streets? MQM has reservations regarding courts yet PTI, JI & PML(N) has belief in courts than why to opt street power first.  Is it good to follow gandhian path of politics for those who claims that they are followers of Allama Iqbal and Jinnah who always preferred to use legal and constitutional ways even in British colonial times.
Is it a reflection of New Pakistan? It is high time to rethink it. Now-a-days all political parties and donors are emphasizing on the role of youth in Pakistan. What message we are giving to our youth?


No comments:

Post a Comment

Punjab & Iqbal

وسیب تے وسنیک علامہ اقبال تے پنجاب عامر ریاض پنجاب تے پنجابی اوہ دو اکھاں جے جس پاروں اساں پنجابی عوام، پنجاب دے وسنیکاں اتے پنجابی وس...