Monday, May 27, 2013

were Jinnah's ancestors Punjabi?......

were Jinnah's ancestors Punjabi?...... 
aamir Riaz
In good old days My friend Imran Khalid once told me sarcastically about a radio talk in which the anchor informed listeners regarding Punjabi dissent of Quaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah's ancestors. My friend declared it Punjabification of Pakistan and repeated radio information that Quaid's ancestors were from the area near to SahiWaal. It was a time when we both were in left circle so such news were part of our entertainment too. I did not know that one day i, myself will write on the line almost similar to that anchor. In the first decade of 21st century, a friend Khalid mahmood, lovely short story writer & poet remind me about a article written in past regarding Nawab Ismail Khan, an old friend of Jinnah. Nawab Sahib was among rare friends of Jinnah who had liberty to tease, making fun of Jinnah. Indeed, like Nawab Bhadar Yar Jang he was among great friends of Jinnah. It was Nawab Ismail Khan who mentioned about ancestors of Jinnah and his reference was none the other then the Jinnah himself. According to him, ancestors of Jinnah came from the area near to Sahiwal in the Punjab and had settled in Kathiwar, Gujrat before settling in Karachi, Sindh.  The same news was confirmed by Hector Bolitho in his biography JINNAH; CREATOR OF PAKISTAN published in 1954, London. This book is recently published by Oxford University Press Pakistan  yet i could not find the important reference of Zamir Niazi in it which was regarding efforts to censor Jinnah's august 11, 1947 speech. In his Urdu book "Ungliaan Fagar Apni" at Page 20 famous journalist cum historian and author of trilogy on Pakistani media, zamir Niazi gave a reference about that incident in which some over smart people tried to stop or censored Jinnah’s August 11, 1947 speech. At page 41, in same book Niazi gave reference of London edition page 197-99 but in current edition it is not there. Anyway, in this reprint at page at Page 2, Bolitho wrote about his meeting with Fatima Bai (a distant bhabi of Jinnah who lived in same house where Jinnah lived) and her son Muhammad Ali Ganji. According to them, Jinnah’s ancestors were belonged to the Punjab, near Multan. They were memons and like many of us were from this land. They never came from outside. So from Punjab they shifted to Kathiwar, Gujrat.
Unfortunately, I also read Urdu translation of Bolithi’s book re-published by Urdu science board, an official institution in 2001. It is an interesting fact that Bolitho started writing this book in 1952. At that time a lot more friends of Jinnah were alive. He met many yet people like H.S.Suhrawrdy, MS Fatima Jinnah, Mumtaz Dautana, Khuro, Hussain Imam were reluctant about that first effort of writing Jinnah’s official biography. Fatima Jinnah did not share Jinnah’s private papers with the author, the fact confirmed by Zuhair sadiquee in his note who did urdu translation. Why MS Fatima Jinnah did not share her notes, it was quite obvious. She knew very well that after the death of her brother things had been changed. Rulers had no passion with historical facts nor interested to know what Quaid said yet they want to change history according to their new needs. Due to that fact she herself started writing a biography and engaged G Allana for that job. G Allana had promised her that he would not share it with General Ayub Khan but than Allana joined Ayub khan and adjusted as representative in UN. So she stopped writing and at her death, there was an incomplete manuscript, almost three chapters found among her papers.

Before sharing this piece I also want to mention some   misleading facts regarding bad urdu translation. The Urdu book published in 1966. In Urdu or hindi, the word communal translated as garohi means from community. In south Asian literature we often read communal politics and generally this term refers to intra-religious affairs. But the term sectarian refers to the affairs related to issues within numerous sects or school of thoughts in a religion. We often read misleading translations of the term communal especially in Urdu books translated in India. Zuhair also followed that path and in many places he translated the word communal as Firqapasti which creates confusion.  Now you read the piece and tries to find original London edition of Bolitho too.


http://dunya.com.pk/index.php/special-feature/2013-05-28/4100#.UaTHnNIwfMY


No comments:

Post a Comment

Punjab & Iqbal

وسیب تے وسنیک علامہ اقبال تے پنجاب عامر ریاض پنجاب تے پنجابی اوہ دو اکھاں جے جس پاروں اساں پنجابی عوام، پنجاب دے وسنیکاں اتے پنجابی وس...