There r too many false claims and
as usual contradictory things in this document. i read it and will soon send my
views. The program is as usual inspired from Congress thesis, anti Punjab
sentiments and Cold war justifications. When our left will able to revisit her
faults? If today left is nowhere, neither in student, peasant unions nor in
labor unions then who is responsible for that? Putting all the blames on
imperialism and state authoritarianism is an old fashion and no one can fool
people with such claims. We are happy as due to this venture we have a new
space within left where we can generate the debate. But the program is as
usual...new liquor in old bottle. If we can find new ways, Newline, new
thinking it will be good otherwise we will still moving in circles.
i will write soon. Yet u can smell
it in my comments too. The writer still using cold war claims for example 1-
write is still sporting Russian military intervention in Afghanistan. 2- Then
when writer is giving examples of sporting military interventions by popular
political parties like PPP or PML Nawaz then he should accept that it was left
too who from pinidi conspiracy till omar asghar launching had such people among
them. 3- If they r using imperialism so in present context are countries like
Russia and china r too includes in it? In cold war we were not include them as
u knew. 4- calling nationalists as racist in general is a bad taste as written
in the document 5- writer accept that in past left did some faults but he did
not give any example nor write any detail just passing remarks. If u r ready to
criticize popular political parties then u have courage to talk about yourselves
too. This r some stray thoughts yet will write in detail soon
aamir riaz
No comments:
Post a Comment